Top 7 Spots for Sweet Treats in Fort Myers

Gourmet coffee and nut covered donuts.

Have a bit of a sweet tooth? Lucky for you, Fort Myers is populated with sweet places to eat. Whether you’re in the mood for a moist cupcake or like to cool down with ice cream on a hot Florida day, Fort Myers has it. Here are our top seven spots for sweet treats in Fort Myers, Florida:

Grace and Shelly’s Cupcakes

A Florida favorite for cupcakes, Grace & Shelly’s Cupcakes come in dozens of different cakes and frostings to satisfy your sweet tooth. Cupcake flavors include Butterfinger, turtle cheesecake, PB&J, raspberry white chocolate, and a dozen others. Looking for something a little more exotic? Grace and Shelly’s even serves up flavors like maple bacon and Froot Loop! Yum.

A gourmet cupcake topped with pecans and carmel.

Among the Flowers

Not just a good place to get coffee and lunch, Among the Flowers has freshly-squeezed juices and gluten-free desserts. You’d never know there isn’t any gluten though – they’re absolutely delectable. Try one of the shop’s “Specialty Sips” like infused coconut water or sunset tea. Need a sweet remedy? The shop’s menu also includes the Immune Tune, the Cure, and the No-Mo Hangover.

Sweet P’s Bakery & Bistro

Sweet P’s Bakery & Bistro is a cute lunch and breakfast spot with a pretty amazing selection of baked goods, including some delicious tarts. Plus, if you’re in the mood for something super rich, dig into one of Sweet P’s cakes They’re made to order!

Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream

A vacation in Florida is never complete without cooling down with an ice cream cone. The perfect place to grab a cool treat on a hot day, Pinocchio’s Original Italian Ice Cream has been churning out homemade ice cream for more than 30 years. Every Pinocchio’s ice cream comes with their calling card: an animal cracker perched on top.


An overflowing ice cream cone with an animal cracker on top.

Heavenly Biscuit

A tiny place with big home-cooked breakfasts, Heavenly Biscuit also cooks up some incredible sweets. They're best known for their Sinful Cinnamon Rolls, but don’t miss out on their bread pudding or pecan rolls. A stop at the Heavenly Biscuit is a must for any Fort Myers vacationer.

A heavenly cinnamon roll. Probably extremely delious and terribly bad for your health..

Norman Love Confections

Are you a chocoholic? If so, Norman Love Confections is your sweet spot. Shop and taste Fort Myers’ best gourmet truffles, dark chocolate, milk chocolate and white chocolate. Be sure to leave room for some artisan gelato by Norman Love too. It’s right next door!


A collection of very pretty candies in display.

Bennett’s Fresh Roast

An absolute must-visit on your sweet tour of Fort Myers is Bennett’s Fresh Roast. Famous for its fresh donuts, Bennett’s serves up more than 20 different varieties including peanut butter, s’mores, orange coconut and maple walnut crunch. Couple a fresh donut with a cup of Joe, and your Florida vacation is officially complete!

A foamy coffe beverage next to an awesome bagel sandwich.

We Think You'll Also Like

Continue Exploring